How to Spot a Quality Lab Diamond (And Why Most Experts Can’t Tell)

At The Real Jewelry Company, we know that today’s jewelry lovers want more than sparkle—they want confidence in what they’re buying. And when it comes to lab diamonds, quality is everything. But here’s the twist: even professional gemologists often can’t tell the difference between a high-quality lab diamond and a natural one without advanced tools.

In this guide, you’ll learn exactly what makes a lab diamond top-tier, how grading works, and what to look for when shopping online—so you can buy with style, smarts, and confidence.

1. What Makes a High-Quality Lab Diamond?

A high-quality lab diamond is one that checks all the same boxes as a natural diamond—brilliance, durability, and flawless beauty. Since lab diamonds are created in a controlled environment, they often boast fewer inclusions and more precise cuts, giving buyers the edge in both quality and price.

Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamond Engagement Rings: What's the Real Difference?

2. The 4 Cs: Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat

Just like natural diamonds, lab diamonds are graded on the famous 4 Cs:

Cut: Determines how brilliantly the diamond sparkles.
Color: The less color, the more valuable. Lab diamonds can achieve near-perfect ratings.
Clarity: Measures imperfections (inclusions). Lab diamonds often rank higher here.
Carat: Refers to the diamond’s weight—bigger isn’t always better, but quality matters.

The Ultimate Diamond Guide: Understanding The 4 Cs - Jonathan Stein

3. Professional Grading & Certification

Quality lab diamonds should always come with professional certification from reputable labs like GIA (Gemological Institute of America) or IGI (International Gemological Institute). Certification provides proof of the diamond’s authenticity, quality, and value.

4. Why Lab Diamonds Pass the “Eye Test”

When placed side-by-side, even experts often can’t distinguish lab diamonds from mined ones with the naked eye. That’s because lab diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds.

Ready to shop with confidence? Explore our certified lab diamond collection at The Real Jewelry Company—crafted for brilliance, beauty, and unbeatable value.

5. Tips for Buying Lab Diamond Jewelry Online

Shopping for lab diamonds online is easier than ever—if you know what to look for:

Always check for certification.
Read customer reviews and store guarantees.
Look for transparent sourcing and grading information.
Compare pricing to ensure you’re getting the best lab diamonds at fair value.

6. Custom vs. Store-Bought Lab Diamond Pieces

With The Real Jewelry Company, you can choose between stunning ready-to-wear pieces or design a custom lab diamond creation that’s uniquely yours. Custom jewelry ensures you get exactly what you want, while store collections provide quick, stylish options that deliver right to your door.

Additional Tips & Common Mistakes to Avoid

Avoid uncertified diamonds—they may not hold value.
Don’t assume bigger is better—focus on cut and clarity for maximum sparkle.
Set a budget upfront—lab diamonds make luxury more accessible, but it’s easy to get carried away with larger stones.

Spotting the Best Lab Diamonds

Lab diamonds offer unmatched brilliance, durability, and ethical value—without the premium price tag of natural stones. By focusing on the 4 Cs, certification, and trusted jewelers, you’ll be able to spot the best lab diamonds with confidence.